Rumor has it, and I know it will come as quite a shock, that the Republicans are getting ready to cave on the budget.
The story is out tonight (Caveat emptor: It comes from Dems) that Democrats and Republicans have generally agreed on figure for the budget cuts in the vicinity of $30bn and that all that remains up in the air is the policy riders, one policy rider in particular.
Let’s talk about the number first and then we will get to the policy riders.
In my lifetime, I have never seen a movement like the tea party. They are a completely grassroots organization that sprung up virtually overnight and immediately began impacting elections. They primaried so-called moderates and helped to deliver one of the most sweeping electoral victories in this nation’s history. And here is the kicker; they are almost a one issue group. Sure, they are about personal freedom in a general way, but there is one issue with which the tea party is primarily identified, cutting spending. And truth be told, for every affiliated member of the tea party, there are a dozen unaffiliated that feel the same way.
As far as electoral messages go, they simply do not get any clearer. Cut spending. Or else.
So now let’s talk about the last 2 1/2 months. It is hard to believe that it has only been ten weeks or so since this congress was sworn in. It took less time than that for Republicans to forget or dismiss every lesson they swore to high heaven that they had learned before the election.
At first they promised $100bn which, let’s face it, is a pimple on an elephants butt compared to this year’s deficit of $1.6 trillion. But before the ink was even dry on that weak pledge, they lowered it to $60bn. Now it looks like they will come in around $30bn. My reaction? Of course. By voting for each short term continuing resolution the Republicans have weakened their bargaining position every day because the Dems know they are scared.
So all they have left to ‘negotiate’ on is the policy riders. And the big kahuna of policy riders is the de-funding of Planned Parenthood. As I said, $100bn, $60bn, or even $30bn in fact makes no real difference in the deficit. They are rounding errors. The Republicans are not really serious about cutting spending. No great shock there.
But they better be serious about the de-funding of Planned Parenthood because it is the only thing that really matters. I don’t mean that in the moral sense, although that is undoubtedly true. I mean it in the political sense. This is the only thing they can actually achieve that will help them politically.
Tea partiers and the like will be rightly be disgusted with anything less than the $60bn mark, and I think it is a foregone conclusion that it will be less than that. So there is one thing and one thing only that Republicans can walk away from this battle with their heads held high, go back to their constituents and say “See? We did it.” And that is de-funding Planned Parenthood.
If they come back with $30bn and a defunded Planned Parenthood, they win. The can promise to go back for more cuts, but they have the political victory. If they come back with $30bn and PP funding still in place, their political goose is cooked.
It is a strange twist that while Republicans have disappointed in the protection of life time and time again, defending life is the only thing that can save them now. This should be obvious. But that is what scares me.
Almost all that has happened over the last 10 weeks that has brought us to this point should have been obvious, but they screwed themselves anyway. The tea-party and other Americans sent an unambiguous message to them just months ago, but they screwed it up. And now they have a chance to pull victory from the jaws of defeat by de-funding PP. It should be obvious. But so much should have been obvious.
And what should also be obvious is that in order to win this victory, the government (at least parts of it) will have to be shut down. You have to make the President shut it down over this, as he has promised to do. Hang that promise around his neck. Make him regret it. Stand strong on this one issue and you can still win.
This is it GOP. This is your last chance. Don’t screw it up.
March 31, 2011 at 5:25 am
I am slightly more forgiving of the GOP and realize the difficulty of cutting the budget in mid season. In many ways I think this slow frawn out process has been productive because it has allowed a discussion over cuts and gives a lay of the ground for big upcoming battle.
That being said there is a flip side to this. Cutting PP and going to mattresses is a big deal and will provoke backlash. I am in the camp that wants to avoid GOVT shutdown because I think that the reaction to that by the public is very unpredictable. Its high stakes and the public is as we have the last 4 years fickle
Regardless Defunding PP will take a lot of political capital of the GOP congress which is fine. I am all for it.
The flip side of that is political capital is not limitless. Which means we got to really back the GOPer that support that cut and stick by it. With our money and our support. If this happens they will come under all out attack that will make what happened in Wisconsin look like a tea party. That means Conservatives cannot just move the goal posts and proclaim betrayal if a few have to cave on other issues or compromise later.
I think it is worth it if PP can be defunded to postpone some battles till next year
So if it happens we better back them.
March 31, 2011 at 10:22 am
Boehner will cave. The "standbyes" will paste together a "bipartisan" coalition which, largely, continues the status quo, in spite of the tea party and inspite of the slide toward insolvency such a "cave" simply ignores. A vague nod of the head toward some "future" deal to address our growing debt and likely ianability to ever pay it off is what
will be the response of the GOP leadership.
More of the same. The election was a useless exercize in misplaced optimism. A very sad, sobering reality. The consensus really is for irresponsibility and self-destruction.
Have a great day!
March 31, 2011 at 1:37 pm
I would like to be surprised, but I probably won't be.
March 31, 2011 at 3:53 pm
If they can't take out planned parenthood, when they are this weak, why on earth should we believe their "we'll try for more next time" is anything but a promise of more failure?
March 31, 2011 at 4:22 pm
The problem is little bit more complicated. Remember, Congress failed to pass a budget in 2010; they've been working off continuing resolutions ever since. The FY 2010 budget expires in September. In normal times it takes months to negociate packages in sub-committee before going to a floor vote. These aren't normal times. Instead of working on the 2011 budget, Congress is debating issues of the 2010 budget, as well as attempting to get stop-gap measures (continuing resolutions) passed every 2-3 weeks.
PP actually gets little of its revenue from Congress. Over $350 million of revenue are from non-taxpayer sources. The vote is symbolic when it comes down to it. However, I don't see why the House doesn't force the issue anyway. If the GOP had its act together it could do 2 things, bring abortion to the front of the line again; and force Reid and Schumer to defend it. The Dems have never really been given a run for thier money. This would be a good time to start. It would also force voters to face reality as it now stands -both morally and fiscally.
March 31, 2011 at 4:30 pm
Jerome-
IIRC, the main gov't funding they get isn't direct, it's by being allowed to charge Medicaid.
March 31, 2011 at 7:12 pm
Just say "NO" like Governor of New Jersey, Chris Christie. "We do not have any money" Boy, we really do not have any money.
April 1, 2011 at 1:40 pm
G.O.P. Grow O Pair
April 3, 2011 at 3:52 am
The Tea Party wants one thing: budget cuts. They could careless about Planned Parenthood, except that it add to the deficit. The sad part is the Tea Party are the antagonist of the Republican Establishment. And even worse, it the economy get better and the unemployed get jobs, less and less people will support the Tea Party movement. The G.O.P. are ruining it for themselves.
April 3, 2011 at 4:10 am
I can't say I agree with you– as "the TEA Party" isn't a single group and doesn't have a leader, we can't say they don't care about this or that.
I do know from the fireworks when those opportunistic SOBs sent their "dump social issues" letter in that a LOT of TEA party sub-groups care very, very much about social issues, and are NOT cool with being hijacked as being libertarian "lower my taxes" folks!
April 3, 2011 at 5:45 pm
It really seems like the G.O.P. continues on it colossal path of failure. Why can't they get their at together?